Here is a complete recap of the shocking events, the ensuing investigation, and the dramatic fallout in the courtroom.

The Fatal Shooting of Det. Vincent Riley

The episode opens with Detective Vincent Riley (Reid Scott) working alone at the station late at night. After unearthing a lead, Riley attempts to contact both his partner, Detective Theo Walker (David Ayala), and Assistant District Attorney Nolan Price (Hugh Dancy), but neither answers.

Riley tracks his suspect to a location near a bar. When the detective calls out to him, the suspect bolts, suddenly turns, and fires two shots directly into Riley's chest. Walker arrives shortly after responding to Riley's earlier message, desperately calling 9-1-1 as his partner bleeds on the street. Tragically, at the hospital, the doctor delivers the devastating news that Riley did not survive.

Investigation and New Faces

Following the tragedy, Lt. Jessica Brady (Maura Tierney) orders a grieving Walker to stay away from the active murder investigation to protect the integrity of the future legal case. Meanwhile, new cast member James Badge Dale joins the precinct as Detective Robert Calvino, a native New Yorker and homicide investigator tasked with taking Walker's statement.

The investigation initially encounters a red herring regarding large sums of money Riley had been withdrawing from his bank. It is soon revealed that the funds were guilt payments made to the pregnant widow of a man Riley had accidentally struck and killed with his car.

Detectives eventually identify the shooter as Ray Biller. Biller is the brother of a man previously prosecuted and convicted by the DA's office who was recently killed in prison. Investigators realize that Biller was actually planning to assassinate ADA Nolan Price, whose apartment was just blocks away from the bar where Riley was shot.

Courtroom Drama and Compromised Testimony

The case takes an ethical detour when Riley's brother, Matt (Ryan Eggold), corners Walker at a bar and pressures him to definitively identify Biller running from the scene, even though Walker never got a clear look at the suspect's face.

Yielding to the pressure, Walker slightly alters his official statement. While this development concerns Price, it pleases District Attorney Baxter, especially since the murder weapon was never recovered. Baxter puts Walker on the stand, where the detective testifies that Ray Biller was unquestionably the man fleeing the bar. Ultimately, the jury finds Biller guilty of murder.

The emotional episode concludes with Lieutenant Brady speaking lovingly of the fallen detective as Detective Vincent Riley's name is officially added to a New York Police Department memorial statue.