As awards season gathers momentum, A24’s documentary “You Can See Everything”—directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim—is generating significant Oscar buzz. Following a surprise world premiere at the Telluride Film Festival in September and an October theatrical release that grossed nearly $80 million domestically through its fourth weekend, industry pundits are predicting the film could make history as the first documentary feature to land a best picture nomination.
Historically, nonfiction films have rarely broken past the Academy's documentary-specific categories. Across 98 Academy Awards ceremonies, feature-length documentaries have earned a total of 33 nominations outside of the documentary feature category, capturing only three competitive wins. No documentary has ever been nominated for best picture or best director, though early precursors included a unique and artistic picture nomination for “Chang: A Drama of the Wilderness” at the inaugural Oscars.
A24 is pushing “You Can See Everything” across multiple races, including best picture, director, supporting actress, and documentary feature, alongside several craft and music categories. However, navigating the Academy's distinct branch structure remains a challenge. While the documentary branch oversees preliminary shortlists and nominations for its own category—with preliminary voting running from Dec. 7 to 11, a 15-film shortlist on Dec. 15, and final nominees announced Jan. 21—the broader best picture category is decided by the entire Academy membership.
Industry observers note that prior documentaries have occasionally found crossover success through music, writing, international features, or craft branches, even when bypassed by the documentary branch itself. As “You Can See Everything” approaches the upcoming Academy shortlists and nomination milestones, its campaign tests the boundaries of how nonfiction storytelling is embraced on Hollywood's biggest stage.

