A Nostalgic Twist: Jacqui Toumbas Shares Her Milk Bar Cookie Recipe

As part of the ABC iview series Recipe of the Year, home cook and food content creator Jacqui Toumbas has shared a deeply personal recipe inspired by her family’s history in Far North Queensland. Her "Milk Bar Cookie" serves as a tribute to the milk bar her grandparents operated in the town of Tully, a cornerstone of the local community for many years.

A Modern Take on a Classic

Toumbas, who grew up in a large Cypriot family, designed the recipe to evoke the nostalgia of the classic Australian milk bar experience. While the base remains a familiar chocolate chip cookie, she has elevated the profile by incorporating brown butter, tahini, and halva. The cookies are finished with dark chocolate and a sprinkle of flaky sea salt, intended to be served warm alongside a glass of cold milk.

For those looking to recreate the treat at home, Toumbas emphasizes the importance of technique. She recommends chilling the dough for 30 minutes in the fridge—or 15 minutes in the freezer—before baking to ensure the best texture. Because the cookies spread significantly during the baking process, she advises limiting trays to six cookies at a time. The dough is also freezer-friendly, remaining viable for up to three months when stored in an airtight container.

The recipe stands as a reflection of the migrant experience in Australia, honoring the generations of families who built community hubs one milkshake and lolly bag at a time.