ISLAMABAD — The Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan (FCCP) has ruled that a uniform 15-year timeline for restoring commuted pensions cannot be applied universally to all retirees, establishing that restoration schedules must instead rely on age-based formulas outlined in applicable provincial service rules.

Under the terms of their retirement, the former employees received half of their pension as a lump-sum commutation and the remaining half as a monthly allowance. The appellants had sought to have their full pensions restored after 15 years in 2012 rather than 2017, pointing to an earlier case involving another retired employee, Mian Muhammad Ishaq, who had received a 15-year restoration.

Setting aside previous Lahore High Court judgments, the FCCP clarified that the previous decision in the Ishaq case was binding only to the specific parties involved and did not create a generalized legal precedent for all PRTC personnel. The court mandated that future calculations must follow the age-dependent framework set forth in the Punjab Civil Services Pension Rules, 1963, while confirming that legally accrued arrears and annual increases remain payable to the retirees.