The 401(k) choice many don’t know they’re making

President Donald Trump has proposed an option to allow more Americans to tap their 401(k) retirement savings to buy a home, but there are two main ways to access 401(k) funds for a down payment: taking a loan from your account or making an early withdrawal. Both options have different financial consequences, and experts warn that tapping into retirement savings can be a costly decision.

According to Eric Croak, a certified financial planner and president of Croak Capital, a 401(k) loan is the "lesser of two evils" because it avoids many of the penalties that come with an early withdrawal. However, there are limits to how much you can borrow, and you'll need to repay the loan with interest. Croak notes that even with these stipulations, a 401(k) loan can strain your monthly budget, especially in the first year of homeownership, when unexpected expenses like repairs and maintenance can arise.

On the other hand, making an early withdrawal from a 401(k) can be more damaging. Not only will you owe ordinary income taxes on the amount you withdraw, but you may also face a 10% early-withdrawal penalty. This can make a large withdrawal end up as a much smaller deposit, and you'll also lose out on the growth that would have happened if those dollars had stayed invested.

Experts warn that retirement accounts are easy to drain and hard to rebuild. If you can't realistically replace the money within the one to two years through higher contributions or dedicated savings, it may be too risky to tap into your 401(k). Even then, it's recommended to take the smallest amount possible, not the maximum your plan allows.

Before considering tapping your 401(k), it's essential to exhaust other options first. These include reducing the target down payment, extending the runway by renting longer, and investigating assistance options. Some cities, like Pawnee City, NE, offer up to $50,000 in down payment assistance to entice residents to move there.

Ultimately, tapping your 401(k) for a down payment should be treated as a last resort. As Croak puts it, "Borrowing from yourself is stealing from your future safety net."